Family Members

family members

Extended family members of EEA nationals

MR and ors (EEA extended family members) Bangladesh [2010] UKUT 449 (IAC)

This case concerned the extended family members of the non EEA national spouse namely, the brother, half-brother and nephew.

The non EEA national’s mother, Mrs. Begum, a Bangladeshi national and widow, was granted leave to enter the UK. The EEA national is Irish and was working in Northern Ireland.  They applied for residence permits to enter the UK and whilst they were initially refused, they won on appeal and Mrs. Begum was admitted to the UK as an elderly dependant. She was a dependant family member in ascending line.

The other applicants (brother, half brother and nephew) do not fall within the definition of Regulation 7 under the Immigration (European Economic Area) regulations 2006 but fall to be treated under reg 8 as extended family members. They argued a discretionary consideration by the Secretary of State for the Home Department (herein after referred to as the SSHD) where deemed appropriate. They were granted entry clearance to join Mr Rahman (the non EEA national) and Mrs. Rahman (the EEA National). They applied for residence cards upon arrival. They were subsequently refused on the basis that they did not qualify as extended family members. Upon appeal, the immigration judge concluded that they were in fact dependants and that the issue was the consideration of the SSHD’s exercise of discretion under reg 17 (4).  The SSHD sought and was granted reconsideration on the point of dependency. The case came before the Upper Tribunal.

Upon consideration of European Community Law and domestic legislation, the Tribunal concluded that it would refer questions to the European Court of Justice (ECJ) for clarification. Those questions are: 

1.           Does Article 3(2) of Directive 2004/38/EC require a Member State to make legislative provision to facilitate entry to and or residence in a Member State to the class of other family members who are not nationals of the European Union who can meet the requirements of Article 10(2)?

2.           Can such other family member referred to in Question 1 rely on the direct applicability of Article 3(2) of Directive 2004/38/EC in the event that he cannot comply with any requirements imposed by national legislative provisions?

3.           Is the class of other family members referred to in Article 3(2) and Article 10(2) of Directive 2004/38/EC limited to those who have resided in the same country as the Union national and his or her spouse, before the Union national came to the host state?

4.           Must any dependency referred to in Article 3(2) of Directive 2004/38/EC on which the other family member relies to secure entry to the host state be dependency that existed shortly before the Union citizen moved to the host state?

5.           Can a Member State impose particular requirements as to the nature or duration of dependency referred to in Article 3(2) of Directive 2004/38/EC by such other family member so as to prevent such dependency being contrived or unnecessary to enable a non national to be admitted to or continue to reside in its territory?

6.           Must the dependency on which the other family member relies in order to be admitted to the Member State continue for a period or indefinitely in the host state for a residence card to be issued or renewed pursuant to Article 10 of Directive 2004/38/EC and if so how should such dependency be demonstrated?

The Upper Tribunal stated that a clearer understanding of Community law would be required in order to determine the appeals. Therefore, once the questions have been answered by the ECJ, a determination will be made on the case.

For further information or for a case specific evaluation, please contact us on 0207 569 3035 or alternatively at
info@ergensharif.co.uk

 
About the Author

At Ergen & Sharif, we can assist you in all aspects of your application as well as advise you as to the prospects of success. Whether you require assistance with the application or whether you would like us to check your documents to ensure everything is in order, we can help/

For further information or for a case specific evaluation, please contact us on 0207 569 3035 or alternatively at
info@ergensharif.co.uk

www.ergensharif.co.uk

 

family member vocabulary – English vocabulary lessons


Fastcamp Tent Mega for 4 Family Members (Instant Pop up Tent)


Fastcamp Tent Mega for 4 Family Members (Instant Pop up Tent)



FASTCAMP Mega for 4-5 Persons is High Level Modle made more firm 3 flame format structure to heighten roof. Set up additional privacy Wall for separated space to protech privacy and store shoes or baggage etc. and upper wide widows and lower ventilation windows added more luxury. WE HIGHLY RECOMMEND Using A TARP and Ground Seat UNDER THE TENT. This tent is designed for Family picnic and casual cam…


Viriber Tactical Gear Clip Web Standard Key Ring Holder Tactical Key Chain Quick Release Key ring Compatible With Molle Bags for Outdoor Activities, a Perfect Key-Holder for a Family Member


Viriber Tactical Gear Clip Web Standard Key Ring Holder Tactical Key Chain Quick Release Key ring Compatible With Molle Bags for Outdoor Activities, a Perfect Key-Holder for a Family Member



The Tritium Key Ring is an easy way to consolidate, organize and deploy multiple sets of keys and key chain tools. This efficient device has three separate key rings joined by two 0.75 inches side release buckles and can attach to your belt, on a tie-down loop in your bag, or you can just carry it in your pocket. You can also join multiple Tritium Key Rings to keep additional sets of keys or key c…


Binboll High Quality-Nylon Tactical Gear Clip Web Standard Key Ring Holder Tactical Key Chain Quick Release Key ring Compatible With Molle Bags for Outdoor Activities, a Perfect Key-Holder for a Family Member


Binboll High Quality-Nylon Tactical Gear Clip Web Standard Key Ring Holder Tactical Key Chain Quick Release Key ring Compatible With Molle Bags for Outdoor Activities, a Perfect Key-Holder for a Family Member



The Tritium Key Ring is an easy way to consolidate, organize and deploy multiple sets of keys and key chain tools. This efficient device has three separate key rings joined by two 0.75 inches side release buckles and can attach to your belt, on a tie-down loop in your bag, or you can just carry it in your pocket. You can also join multiple Tritium Key Rings to keep additional sets of keys or key c…


Spanish Language School Poster - Words About Family Members - Wall Chart for Home and Classroom - Bilingual: Spanish and English Text


Spanish Language School Poster – Words About Family Members – Wall Chart for Home and Classroom – Bilingual: Spanish and English Text


$7.99


Spanish language learning on your walls! With this colorful poster you can decorate your kids room, your classroom, the walls of a Spanish club, museum or association. It is also a great gift for Spanish language teachers and for parents and grandparents teaching Spanish to their children. This simplified chart with Spanish words about family members will make learning fun and an everyday effortl…